Audio By Carbonatix
Our latest Chow Bella showdown: a traditional holiday cookie exchange. Today: our final entry, Amy Silverman’s “The Holidays Really Take Their Toll (House) Cookies.”
Let’s face it: You’ve made it this far in the holiday season and all you really want right now is a stiff drink (we’ve got plenty of coverage to that end, here on Chow Bella). But you’ve got one more batch of cookies to whip up. Might I suggest a classic? The Nestle Toll House cookie.
The best part: You can’t lose the recipe. It’s right there on the freaking bag. I like to go to Safeway, pick up a bag of chocolate chips and use that as my shopping list.
When news happens, Phoenix New Times is there —
Your support strengthens our coverage.
We’re aiming to raise $30,000 by December 31, so we can continue covering what matters most to you. If New Times matters to you, please take action and contribute today, so when news happens, our reporters can be there.
You really can’t go wrong with these, as long as you let the butter soften enough (otherwise, and I know this from experience, you’ll have big lumps of butter in your cookies; or if you nuke the butter to liquid they’ll be hard as rocks).
I won’t share the recipe — that’s ridiculous, you can pick up a bag of chips yourself, Walgreen’s even carries them — but I’ll offer up my secret for making perfect chocolate chip cookies. It’s one I learned quite by accident. A few years ago, my Toll House cookies were receiving rave reviews and I couldn’t figure out why. It was simply the recipe on the bag. Then I realized I was unintentionally doubling the amount of chocolate chips I put in each batch.
Having poor math skills can pay off sometimes.
I tried to get creative with this batch, and tossed not only semi-sweet but also white chocolate chips in the batter, along with some peanuts and pistachios I happened to have in the cupboard. Frankly, I think I prefer the original version, but these were okay, too.
Warning: M&Ms are fine to put in your cookies, but I don’t recommend adding candy corn (I know, different holiday) unless you want a real mess.
Another tip for saving time: Press your dough into a well-greased brownie pan and make cookie bars. Enjoy!
The Chow Bella Christmas Cookie Exchange — so far: 12. Carol Blonder’s Mango-Pine Nut Rugelach11. Shannon Armour’s Lemon Crunch Cookies 10. Shannon Armour’s Chocolate Crinkle Cookies 9. Jennifer Woods’ Aunt Bonnie’s Sour Cream Cookies 8. Lauren Saria’s Cream Cheese-Filled Snickerdoodles7. Ando Muneno’s Totally Ethnic Ginger Chocolate Cookies 6. Dominique Chatterjee’s Mini Dark Chocolate Pear Tarts 5. Erica O’Neil’s Salty Sweet Choco-Pretzel Brown Butter Bombs 4. Claire Lawton’s Chocolate Chip, Fool Proof and Better Than They Look Cookies
3. Nicole Smith’s Mini Pans 2. Amy Morris’ Snickerdoodles and Spritz Cookies
