Critic's Notebook

You Asked For It: Broken Poets

Band: Broken Poets Record: Everything In Nature Basics: An indie duo that recently re-tooled their sound to emphasize Tom McDonald's deep, brooding voice, the Poets have a the same vibe you'll find in the slowest Death Cab for Cutie songs. Though they at times sound a lot like the standard...
Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

Band: Broken Poets
Record: Everything In Nature
Basics: An indie duo that recently re-tooled their sound to emphasize Tom McDonald’s deep, brooding voice, the Poets have a the same vibe you’ll find in the slowest Death Cab for Cutie songs. Though they at times sound a lot like the standard alt-rock fare you’ll hear on, say, The Edge, this is a very high-minded band. They’ve got a manifesto here and a long statement on the back of their record that begins, “The songs on this record were inspired by the realization that my place in the world is directly related to my relationship with nature…”

Best Song: “Once Before” starts out with a great little riff reminiscent of Coldplay. “My Station,” has the best tempo on the whole record, speeding and slowing at several points to create a great vibe.
Worst Song: The record tails off toward the end with “Last Ressurection of the First Bob Dylan” and “The Matriarch” both lacking the verve some of the rest of this record has.
Suggested Changes: I’d desperately like to hear Broken Poets vary their pace more, as the slow speed and the relatively simple tracks backing McDonald’s powerful voice get a bit boring after awhile. The band has found it’s sound — but it needs to branch out a bit.
Grade: B

When news happens, Phoenix New Times is there —
Your support strengthens our coverage.

We’re aiming to raise $30,000 by December 31, so we can continue covering what matters most to you. If New Times matters to you, please take action and contribute today, so when news happens, our reporters can be there.

$30,000

GET MORE COVERAGE LIKE THIS

Sign up for the Music newsletter to get the latest stories delivered to your inbox

Loading latest posts...